Showing posts with label liquidity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label liquidity. Show all posts

Monday, October 13, 2008

The immediate crisis is passing ... what the future must look like ...

Yes, the immediate crisis is now in the process of passing, with all the extraordinary measures taken to assure the financial system remains liquid. There will still be, perhaps, moments of further high-wire acts over the next 12-24 months, but these now appear less likely to take down the entire financial system, given the exceptional world-wide commitment to blitzkrieg measures as necessary.

I think that, given the unbelievable bungling by companies, CEOs , and boards in the banking and insurance sectors, a round of applause is due to central banks, and governments, world-wide in managing the crisis. This isn't the same as saying that they took measures to prevent the crisis from arising but, once it was upon us, took appropriate measures to make sure this didn't become "The Great Depression, II".

Given the enormous failure of systemic corporate foresight and governance on an individualized corporate basis, governments must now take steps to regulate systemic strength and redundancy into both the banking and insurance sectors. The government must also reform obscene and excessive-risk-encouraging executive pay schemes, since boards have clearly failed to perform their duties to protect shareholders in particular and, as a group, their actions have endangered society in particular.

Here's some quick thoughts on what some of this regulation can and should look like (by the way, corporate boards, take some notes in case this doesn't get legislated, as it's still solid corporate practice: good and prudent governance, if you will):

Banking:
Never again allow the total disconnect between the lender and borrower to occur, by mandating that any pools of capital moved "off balance sheet" (i.e. sold to hapless investors), have some significant portion retained by the originating institution. Whether that amount is 15%, 25% or 50% should be thought about carefully, with the two competing objectives of robustness of system, and efficiency of capital, duly and thoughtfully considered.

The FDIC and similar institutions need to consider "100 year events" in pricing their deposit insurance, as secular increases or declines playing out over a couple of decades can hide fundamental flaws in this type of insurance pricing (i.e. the current scenario). The pricing needs to properly reflect the risk of the loan book of a particular institution - in other words, those playing in areas of the pool with no lifeguard, need to have appropriately steep insurance costs to discourage the most egregious type of risk-taking - or alternatively, to protect the general public when the inevitable failures occur. More highly levered institutions also need to pay higher premiums.

Insurance/Banking:
Anything that looks or smells like some sort of insurance scheme is appropriately reserved. This means that pretty much anything that is insurance against some other event, and involves a trade (swap) of potential event happenings, or pricings etc. It doesn't take a financial genius to recognize that things that are "insurance" aren't always called "insurance". Here's some keywords for regulators, boards and investors to think as insurance: "hedge", "swap", "obligation" (in certain contexts), "derivatives", and so on. No longer should these be allowed to be unreserved. They are all some type of insurance, and need appropriate regulation and reserving to recognize those risks.

Pay schemes:
Federally regulated industries need to have banned, outright, stock option grants. Options encourage excessive risk taking, without the offsetting consideration to downside risk. A winner take all mentality, if you will. This must be discouraged, as it produces unacceptable systemic risk.

In fact, had boards collectively produced proper and appropriate compensation schemes, I argue that much of these systemic excesses may never have happened. For further thoughts on executive pay reform, go here. (In fact, I'd now go one step further and say that the CEO should have to own stock equivalent to at least two years base pay during his entire tenure + eighteen months, as CEO).



JW

The Confused Capitalist

Monday, April 17, 2006

Groovy man! Are the Seventies Back?

Now, I've been saying this for just about two years. For those old enough to remember, do these times remind anyone of the 1970s (sans hippies, of course)?

We've got an increasingly unpopular war, that seems increasingly like it's going to last longer and longer, consuming more and more money. A war that started in a fervor of patriotism, increasingly questioned by the populace at large.

We've got foreign companies nipping at the heels of American companies - in the 70s, the re-emergence of post-war Germany and Japan; today, the rise of China and India.

A flood of liquidity into the market, that seems to be fuelling inflation beyond that recognized by "the powers that be".

A real estate market in ascendancy.

Gold on the rise. A large federal deficit.

Fuel costs spiraling ever upwards, it seems.

Now, I remember how it all ended ...

Is it just me, or is this the 1970s redux?


JW

The Confused Capitalist

Support this blog and our advertisers: check out the advertised listings.

Saturday, April 15, 2006

Ring, ring. Ring, ring. (Hello, is anybody there?)

And who says they don't ring a bell at the market top (or close to it)!

I think that the US market is very close to a top for the next several years, and it isn't because stocks are overly expensive. There's been lots of research showing that, relative to recent historical norms, stocks remain at roughly fair value (I'd define fair value as within 10% of its perfect actual value). The PE ratio of the S&P500 at about 18 or 19 isn't something to get alarmed about.

What is, is the rising interest rates. This will drain liquidity from the market as rates will be - I predict - rising far above that foreseen by most commentators today. That's because interest rates aren't just used to control inflation - but to support a weakened currency and attract needed outside financing, when a deficit situation exists when internal lenders no longer buy enough bonds to support the deficit (i.e. the USA today). In two years, I predict that a 30 year fixed mortgage will be in the 8.5% to 10.5% range, between 200 to 400 basis points higher than today.

Secondarily, the downdraft from the real estate market (expect that to be a serious force about 12 months from now), will also drain liquidity from stocks, as some owners of investment or secondary real estate, will partially cash out of the stock market to support their increased real estate loan payments. Others will sell their investment or secondary homes, but with the stock market also in a secular decline, won't redeploy their additional capital (if that exists for them), into the stock market. They'll keep it on the sideline in CDs and other savings intruments that will have relatively attractive yields.

Finally, the yields of savings instruments will continue to become more attractive, and will also compete for cash that recently was almost automatically deployed into the stock market, or real estate.

Real estate and the stock market returns will be well correlated over the next three to five years. Negative returns. Or am I the only one that hears the bell ringing?


JW

The Confused Capitalist

Support this blog and our advertisers: check out the advertised listings.